The public gets it, part 2

From restaurants to daycare to yarn

Incorruptible: Why Good Companies Go Bad…

and How Great Companies Stay Great

Available to order at incorruptible.co

Back in July, I told you about some grim private equity buyout deals that had been shared with me by members of the Incorruptible community. I referred to these as “the public gets it” stories; it’s now time for the next installment in this unfortunately long-running series, courtesy of the latest article about PE’s continued destruction of beloved local restaurant chains. 

Restaurants tend to get a lot of the attention, but readers used the comments on this story to open the floodgates wide on all the other ways in which private equity is destroying their communities. As one of them summed it up: “Welcome to private equity USA. We are now your heating air conditioning, gardening, roofing, plumbing, Roto-Rooter business yada yada yada and we’re gonna charge you twice as much for the exact same service.”

Here are a few more comments that show just how far the wreckage has spread:

“Private equity destroyed a small birthing center my colleagues were employed by. Cost cutting measures and reduced pay for staff forced it to shut down and left a dozen employees without jobs and the community with one less option to birth in.”

“I do know of a once highly respected Connecticut newspaper purchased by private equity in 2021. The Hartford Courant went from an important news gathering and information disseminating publication with a thoroughly professional and dedicated staff to the desiccated shadow disseminating warmed over press releases and vapid puff pieces that it is now.”

“Can we add daycare to the list of businesses with private equity backing? Between private equity, franchises (like Goddard and Primrose), and chains (like kindercare and bright horizons) it's so hard to find quality daycare. Bright horizons came in and took over our nonprofit and it was so awful. They make a 25% profit off each of their centers.”

The general tone has shifted from enraged to existential (my emphases throughout):

“The landscape is littered with the corpses of many of these deals.”

“They milk our residual trust, counting on us to patronize a beloved establishment out of habit for a few years, even as the flavors decline. By the time we collectively realize the food has lost its soul, the private equity firm has already extracted its dividends and exited, leaving behind a hollowed-out ghost of a once-great restaurant”

“Private Equity is emblematic of the country at this point in time. It is “smash and grab”, the looting and pillaging of a functional system made possible by moral decay and rot at the highest levels.”

The piece notes that “The overarching concern voiced by many customers has been their feeling of helplessness as private equity encroaches into more aspects of public life”. 

But the comments are filled with a rising sense of agency and an understanding that there’s a real difference between incorruptible companies – built to choose mission over money – and the rest (again, my emphases throughout):  

“I am an avid knitter and PE has taken over our industry. From online stores to yarn companies, we are seeing more and more PE acquisitions. The customers, at least most of us, are fighting back and no longer supporting the companies that we once did”

“I actively try to avoid patronizing any business that is backed by private equity. Others have mentioned medical and veterinary care--both of which have been ravaged by PE. I see the same thing in home services like HVAC, plumbing, electrical, etc. as well as in the boutique fitness industry. Businesses should have to divulge their ownership when asked.”

“I look up everything before I buy now: “Who owns _______?” If it’s a conglomerate or private equity, I won’t buy it. I look for an alternative that hasn’t sold out yet or I forgo the product if there’s no alternative.”

“Greed is self destructive. P.E.and other forms of investment that kill our ability to live affordable, respectable lives need to be banned. We need a new financial model.”

Even as I was writing this, someone sent me the news that The Children’s Place, founded in 1969, has declared bankruptcy. The comments on that story are every bit as wise to what’s gone wrong as the ones above: “As part of the original TCP team, when the brand was thriving, the past few years have been painful to watch!! Someone needs to step in and get back to the original mission,” a former employee bemoaned. Another person noted: “Boards kill more businesses than anything else. Because their primary focus is to line their pockets by any means necessary. Not to grow and develop a business strategically over time.”

Every one of these voices is crucial to changing the financial gravity that has dragged us down for too long. 

Rita McGrath of Columbia University Business School, is one of the world’s top experts on strategy and innovation. She is consistently ranked among the top 10 management thinkers in the world.

For those of you who love management thinking, this conversation with Rita covers all kinds of topics.

Rita recently published an article in Fast Company entitled "Shareholder Capitalism is anything but good for shareholders" which is worth checking out, too. Spoiler: we're quite aligned.

If these topics of conversation are interesting to you, you’re invited to join the free Incorruptible Community to connect with people committed to building organizations that last, including founders, executives, investors, employees, and customers. 

We’re hosting a free virtual workshop session on Wednesday, November 18 on mission drive and how to build metrics around it. All are welcome.